Best family Christmas films
The ones that work with everyone in the room — small children, teenagers who are pretending not to enjoy it, and whoever falls asleep by nine. Scored on how festive they actually are, with a straight answer on whether the kids can watch.
Festive Factor: 96The Muppet Christmas Carol1992The Dickens adaptation that respects the text most, which is not the joke it sounds like.
Festive Factor: 95Arthur Christmas2011The best-argued Santa logistics ever put on screen, and genuinely funny with it.
Festive Factor: 90Elf2003Sincere without being sickly, which is much harder than it looks.
Festive Factor: 87The Polar Express2004Divisive on looks, unarguable on atmosphere. Best on the biggest screen you have.
Festive Factor: 88Home Alone1990The one that holds a mixed room. Loud enough for the children, mean enough for the adults.
Festive Factor: 87Nativity!2009Chaotic in the way a real school nativity is chaotic. Recognition is most of the pleasure.
Festive Factor: 82Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger!2012Broader than the first and it knows it. Fine if the first one went down well; not the one to start with.
Festive Factor: 72It's a Wonderful Life1946A grown-ups' film that children can watch rather than a children's film. Slow to start, and worth it.
Festive Factor: 66The Snowman1982Twenty-six minutes, no dialogue, and it will still get someone. Know that going in.
Every film here has been watched and scored on the same two numbers, and every one carries a line about what the youngest person in the room is in for. That is the whole point: "family film" is doing a lot of work in most lists, and it usually means nobody has checked.
They are ordered by Festive Factor, so the top of the list is the most Christmassy rather than the most acclaimed. If you want the one that will hold a mixed room for ninety minutes, start there and work down.