Skip to content

The annual Christmas debate

Edward Scissorhands.
Christmas film?

Not really. Edward Scissorhands is mostly set outside the season, even though Christmas appears on screen: it scores 34 out of 100 on our Festive Factor and 54 on Cosiness, ratified against our published rubric.

Edward Scissorhands is told on a snowy night, and its best-known image is snow falling over a Christmas party. It feels wintry from the first frame.

Most of the film, though, takes place in a pastel suburb that rarely looks like winter. Christmas arrives late, as the setting for the climax rather than the subject of the story. On the rubric that means low setting saturation and a real case for Winter rather than Christmas.

It is a Halloween film for a lot of people too: UK searches for it peak in October, not December. That makes it a good test of the difference between the ruling and Festive Factor. Decide whether the snow is doing the work that Christmas is getting the credit for.

Sources

Updated 16 October 2026

That is our ruling. This is yours: what CineClaus readers say, counted as the votes come in.

Readers’ poll

Is Edward Scissorhands a Christmas film?

Voting needs JavaScript switched on.

Our answers. Your call.

Here is the working, line by line.

Our answers are loaded. Change any line you disagree with; the certificate keeps up. How the questions work. Rubric v1.3.

10 of 11 answers recorded · Question 1 of 11

Plot dependency · up to 30 points

Take Christmas out. Does the plot survive?

Take Christmas out. Does the plot survive?

An example certificate