2 November · 53 days to ChristmasThe advent calendar opens 1 December →

Original painted Christmas scene, from the Cine Claus illustration set

Essential Christmas · 2004

A Christmas Carol: The Musical

Name: A Christmas Carol: The Musical
Released: 2004
Duration: 97 min

66/100Festive FactorWhy it scores 66 ↓

Not BBFC rated97 min · TV special
Family · Musical

The Dickens story with the songs turned up, and the songs are the reason to watch.

On Prime Video · UK subscription →

Plan this film night ↓Can the kids watch? ↓

+ Add to a list

Explore this film 4 sections

The CineClaus Christmas score

Festive Factor

Christmas all the way through.

Five ingredients make the Festive Factor.
Open an ingredient to find out more.

Christmas in the storyChristmas drives it, but another occasion could stand in.20/30

What we ask: Take Christmas out. Does the plot survive? Worth up to 30 of the 100 points.

A world dressed for ChristmasVisibly Christmas for most of it.15/20

What we ask: How much of the running time is visibly Christmas? Worth up to 20 of the 100 points.

The little seasonal details5 of the 10 kinds of Christmas icon we count turn up on screen.8/15

What we ask: How many kinds of Christmas icon turn up on screen: trees, lights, snow, carols and the rest? Worth up to 15 of the 100 points.

A Christmas heartHow far the ending rests on goodwill, family and belief: entirely.20/20

What we ask: Does the ending depend on what Christmas means: goodwill, family, redemption, belief? Worth up to 20 of the 100 points.

A returning traditionNiche at Christmas (under 25,000).3/15

What we ask: Is it actually watched at Christmas in the UK? Worth up to 15 of the 100 points.

72/100

Cosiness Rating Rating

Warm in tone. Moderate threat. A happy ending.

How we score →

What do these scores mean?

Festive Factor measures how Christmassy a film is. Five ingredients add up to 100: story (30), setting (20), seasonal details (15), emotional heart (20) and returning tradition (15).

Cosiness is a separate score for warmth of tone, sense of safety, visual comfort, a reassuring ending and how easily you can settle into it.

How the Festive Factor works →

Your next film night

Where to watch

United KingdomChecked 30 Oct 2026

Prime Video

Included with a subscription

In the catalogue

Apple TV

Rent or buy

See viewing options on Apple TV (opens in a new tab)

Prime Video

Rent or buy

See viewing options on Prime Video (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)

A Christmas Carol: The Musical · Rental and purchase cost extra, separately from membership.

As an Amazon Associate, Cine Claus earns from qualifying purchases. Buying through a link helps pay for the site - it never changes a score.

Streaming changes constantly and we cannot promise it is still right - check the service before you settle in. Streaming availability information provided by Streaming Availability API by Movie of the Night (opens in a new tab).

The story

About A Christmas Carol: The Musical

A television musical built on the Menken and Ahrens stage show, retelling Dickens on Christmas Eve. A tight-fisted moneylender, Scrooge, is visited by his late partner Marley and three spirits who walk him through his past, the present and a grim future. Songs carry the story, and on Christmas morning he rushes to the Cratchit family to put things right.

The CineClaus verdict

The Dickens story with the songs turned up, and the songs are the reason to watch.

Alan Menken's tunes carry a faithful retelling from Christmas Eve night to the morning after, with Kelsey Grammer playing Scrooge as a man more wounded than wicked. The ghost number with the chains is properly spooky and the graveyard stretch will worry small children.

The finish is warm and loud and sung together. Put it on for a family that likes a sing-along more than a snowball of sentiment.

The family desk

Can the kids watch?

Not BBFC rated

Our take: fine from about eight, though the chained ghosts and the graveyard scene can frighten younger children.

Content advice & accessibility

Not BBFC rated: The BBFC has no classification for this film, so it has no UK certificate. Our age guidance above is editorial, not an official rating.